TOP RATED PLUS SELLER · 18,000+ ACTIVE LISTINGS

Same- or next-business-day handling on every order. Each card ships in a penny sleeve and rigid holder inside a protective mailer, from a smoke-free home. 30-day returns, and any question gets a real answer from the owner, not a script.

Why This Card Matters

The back is built around one good story, told in his own words: “When Toussaint was informed of his promotion to the bigs by Triple-A Gwinnett manager Damon Berryhill, he called his mom, who asked if he was sure his manager was being serious.” And the quote underneath: “Honestly, when you are told, it doesn’t hit you. Then when you go out there, it doesn’t hit you.” His 2018 Atlanta line reads 7 games, 5 starts, 29 innings, 32 strikeouts and a 4.03 ERA. Born June 20, 1996 in Coral Springs, Florida; 6'3", 185 pounds, right-handed.

Market-Informed Pricing

Priced from verified sold comps on this exact card and this exact version, not from asking prices or guesswork. Best Offer is enabled and every reasonable offer gets a look.

Professional Imaging

High-resolution scans and photos so you can inspect corners, edges, surface, and centering yourself. What you see is what you get.

Secure Shipping

Penny sleeve, top loader or card saver, team bag, and rigid protection in every shipment. Packed right, shipped fast, from a smoke-free environment.

“Rated Rookie”, Not “RC” — and Optic Is Not Paper Donruss

Two things worth being exact about. First, Panini is not MLB-licensed and does not use the RC logo — it uses the Rated Rookie shield instead, which this card carries on the front and back. It is a rookie-year card, just not an RC-logo card. Second, Donruss Optic is chromium and paper Donruss shares the same numbering, so check the stock: this is the Optic. Not the Holo Prizm, Purple /125, Purple Stars /125, Purple Pandora /99, Blue Prizm /60, Pink Velocity /199, Teal Velocity /35, Carolina Blue & White, Red Wave, Green Cracked Ice /7, Rookie Prizm SP /99, We The People /76, Red White & Blue 150th /150 or Black /25.